New York Gothams 1889

46 Wins, 50 Losses, Ranked: 6

William Brown
Roger Connor
Ed Crane
Buck Ewing
Elmer Foster
Bill George
George Gore
Gil Hatfield
Tim Keefe
Harry Lyons
Pat Murphy
Hank O'Day
Jim O'Rourke
Danny Richardson
Mike Slattery
Mike Tiernan
Ledell Titcomb
John Ward
Mickey Welch
Art Whitney