New York Gothams 1886

46 Wins, 50 Losses, Ranked: 6

Gene Bagley
Ed Caskin
Roger Connor
Larry Corcoran
Pat Deasley
Jim Devlin
Frank Diven
Mike Dorgan
Dude Esterbrook
Buck Ewing
Bill Finley
Joe Gerhardt
Patrick Gillespie
Tim Keefe
Jim O'Rourke
Danny Richardson
John Ward
Mickey Welch