New York Gothams 1884

46 Wins, 50 Losses, Ranked: 6

Ed Bagley
Jim Brown
Ed Caskin
Roger Connor
Mike Dorgan
Buck Ewing
Patrick Gillespie
Sandy Griffin
Frank Hankinson
John Humphries
Bill Loughran
Charlie Manlove
Alex McKinnon
Henry Oxley
Danny Richardson
John Ward
Mickey Welch