Brooklyn Atlantics 1886

40 Wins, 64 Losses, Ranked: 9

Ernie Burch
Bob Clark
John Harkins
Hardie Henderson
Ed Kennedy
Jim McCauley
Bill McClellan
Jim McTamany
Dave Oldfield
Jimmy Peoples
Bill Phillips
George Pinkney
Henry Porter
Pop Schriver
Germany Smith
Joe Strauss
Ed Swartwood
Adonis Terry
Steve Toole