Brooklyn Atlantics 1885

40 Wins, 64 Losses, Ranked: 9

Frank Bell
John Cassidy
John Harkins
Jackie Hayes
Mike Hines
Pete Hotaling
Bill Krieg
Bill McClellan
Jim McTamany
George McVey
Dave Oldfield
Jimmy Peoples
Bill Phillips
George Pinkney
Henry Porter
Charlie Robinson
Bill Schenck
Germany Smith
Phenomenal Smith
Ed Swartwood
Adonis Terry